Pros
- Several colors to choose from
- Great for cold weather
Cons
- Hand wash only
This Carhartt beanie is about as tried and true as they come. The traditional cuffed style with the pom-pom for flair makes it a staple to any cold weather excursions, like sledding or skiing. Plus, while everyone has the original Carhartt beanie, this one adds a little uniqueness to a beloved style.
Rave Review: “This hat is wonderful! It fits perfectly. It’s the warmest hat I’ve ever owned. I live in a cold weather climate and this hat keeps me so warm.”
Pros
- Lined with fleece for extra warmth
- Several color options
Cons
- Can run small
If you’re looking for added warmth, this Under Armour beanie comes fleece-lined. The snug fit keeps it in place during any activity, and the price won’t break the bank. The durable, knit stretch makes it perfect for more strenuous adventures, but it’s also stylish enough to spruce up a winter outfit.
Rave Review: “It’s also much warmer than other hats I’ve bought in the past. It certainly lives up to the quality I would expect from Under Armour.”
Best Colorful Beanie
Madewell (Re)sourced Cuffed Beanie
Best Colorful Beanie
Madewell (Re)sourced Cuffed Beanie
Now 49% Off
Pros
- Made from recycled materials
- Maintains integrity after a wash, per reviews.
Cons
- Only comes in one size
This Madewell cuffed beanie is trendy and well-made. It’s made to last through multiple seasons, and it comes in 11 different colors. Several happy customers say they’ve re-purchased this item in different shades, and love how it looks and feels on their head. Plus, cuffed beanies are all the rage right now, and it looks so classic that it’ll probably never go out of style.
Rave Review: “I have multiple colors and rotate them throughout the year (even in summer). They are thick, but not stiff, warm but not itchy, and fit my weird melon perfectly.”
| Material | Recycled cotton blend |
|---|
Pros
- Removable pom-pom
- Many color options
Cons
- Hand wash recommended
Look, pom-poms aren’t for everyone. But if you like the option of having a pom, this hat has a removable one. The tight-knit hat looks good with and without the adornment, and as a bonus, there are so many colors and patterns to choose from.
Rave Review: “I love this hat. It’s warm and comfortable and looks the same as the picture. I have very long dreads and this hat fits perfectly over my head.”
Best Fisherman Beanie
Roybens Fisherman Beanie
Best Fisherman Beanie
Roybens Fisherman Beanie
Now 25% Off
Pros
- Stylish
- Many colors to choose from
Cons
- Not made to cover your ears
Fisherman beanies are shorter and they don’t cover your ears, so they may not be as warm as other options. They can sure elevate any outfit, though. This one comes in various colors and you can even get a pack of three. You’ll totally channel your inner Jackson from Gilmore Girls, too.
Rave Review: “Fit is awesome—not too much material and not too warm in a good way, so I can wear it more days of the year.”
| Material | Wool and acrylic knit |
|---|
Most Stylish Beanie
Everlane The ReCashmere Beanie
Most Stylish Beanie
Everlane The ReCashmere Beanie
Pros
- Soft, warm material
- Eco-friendly
Cons
- Hand wash only
For those searching for the softest, warmest material that looks good, too, cashmere is the perfect option. (And BTW, Berlin swears cashmere is the best material for a beanie.) This one from Everlane comes from a blend of recycled cashmere and wool. At $75, it’s on the pricier side, but you’ll gain a reliable, stylish beanie in the process.
Plus, the fact that it is sustainably made with recycled cashmere is reason enough for it to be on this list.
Rave Review: “I added this beanie to my order as an afterthought and it’s turned out to be my favorite thing. I’ve worn it nearly every day.”
| Material | Recycled cashmere |
|---|
Best Cotton Beanie
Madewell Recycled Cotton Cuffed Beanie
Best Cotton Beanie
Madewell Recycled Cotton Cuffed Beanie
Pros
- Eco-friendly
- Machine washable
Cons
- Only one color to choose from
Cotton might not be the best choice for warmth, but it does offer an alternative to those who have cashmere or wool allergies, Berlin says. She recommends wearing it in the fall or spring. Madewell’s cuffed yellow beanie adds a pop of color to any outfit without breaking the bank. Plus, it’s made of recycled cotton, so you’re helping Mother Earth while keeping warm.
Rave Review: “The fabric content is very nice—soft with zero scratchiness, breathable and thick enough for Wisconsin winter weather.”
| Material | Recycled cotton and polyester |
|---|
Best Athletic Beanie
Lululemon Run For It All Beanie
Best Athletic Beanie
Lululemon Run For It All Beanie
Pros
- Reflective details for night running
- Hole to thread your ponytail through
Cons
- Might not suit curly hair
The grind doesn’t stop in the winter months. If you find yourself running in the cold, Lululemon’s athletic beanie will keep you warm. It has reflective material for optimal road running and a ponytail hole to thread your hair through. Some reviews suggest it’s not the best for curly hair, though, so keep that in mind when buying.
Rave Review: “I was looking for a fleece-lined running/walking hat, and this fits over my ears perfectly. Just make your ponytail is lower and there aren’t any problems!”
Pros
- Great for extremely cold weather
- Cost-effective
Cons
- Washing instructions unknown
If you’re doing any hiking or camping in extremely cold temperatures, the North Face beanie should be your go-to. It’s made from a wool blend and reviews say its snug fit keeps it in place all day. And if you’re not into showing off a logo on your clothes, this one seamlessly hides it with the same-colored stitching.
Rave Review: “The material is VERY thick, causing it to be an extremely warm hat. The material is soft and comfortable, not at all itchy, so I don’t mind wearing it all day if needed.”
Best Beanie For Warmth
Columbia Slowcamp Cuffed Beanie
Best Beanie For Warmth
Columbia Slowcamp Cuffed Beanie
Pros
- Made from recycled materials
- Lightweight, but warm
Cons
- Hard to style
This Columbia beanie is sure to keep your head warm, without making it sweat. Its tri-blend materials will provide a cozy feeling—and its five color options will ensure you’ll find a hat you love. Sadly, this baby only comes in one size, but its stretch will be sure to sit gracefully atop any head.
Rave Review: This Slowcamp style is fairly new from Columbia, so there aren’t any reviews quite yet, but trust: their beanies are very well-liked. “Quality is outstanding and it definitely protects my head from the elements,” writes one reviewer of Columbia beanies.
| Material | Rayon, cotton, polyester |
|---|
Pros
- Designed for cold weather
- Fun colors
Cons
- Not the best if you’re looking for a tight fit
Hush Puppies’ beanie hats come in fun color options, like cow print and deep teal. The colorful beanies are made with soft acrylic yarn, which makes each hat extra warm and cozy. Each one features the super cute Hush Puppies dog logo, too. Awww.
Rave Review: “Super cute beanie, lovely color, and I especially love the tag with the basset hound! Very comfortable and wide brim allows for ample adjustment.”
Best Trendy Beanie
Carhartt Carhartt Women’s Rib Knit Beanie
Best Trendy Beanie
Carhartt Carhartt Women’s Rib Knit Beanie
Pros
- Comes in tons of colors
- Actually keeps you warm
Cons
- A lot of people have it
Carhartt’s beanies are a solid pick for any season, given their trendiness—but they actually keep you warm in the winter, and are breathable enough to wear in the warmer months, too. Made of 100 percent acrylic rib knit, you will feel super comfortable and warm in this beanie—no matter when or how long you wear it.
Editor’s Review: “This beanie is a staple for me, and almost everyone in my family. I love the classic look, and it actually keeps me really warm in even below negative temperatures.” —Olivia Evans, editorial assistant
Most Unique Beanie
C.C C.C Exclusives Cable Knit Beanie
Most Unique Beanie
C.C C.C Exclusives Cable Knit Beanie
Now 13% Off
Pros
- Fit is perfect, according to reviews
- High quality for a low price
Cons
- Slouchy fit
The C.C. beanie trend might have come and gone, but these hats were popular for a reason! The ribbed style gives it a unique look compared to other options on this list. Plus, the stretchy acrylic fabric makes it comfortable and warm for any trip.
Rave Review: “The color and design is super eye-catching, and it fits just right—snug but stretchy. Plus, it’s warm, making it my go-to for winter backpacking trips. Highly recommend for anyone seeking both style and function!”
Pros
- Neutral, so it’s easy to style
- Doesn’t slide around/tight fitting
Cons
- Hand wash only
Where are the Alo girlies at? This tight-fit beanie will be the perfect neutral accent to your winter outfits. It comes in grey, beige, and black—so you’ll never have trouble mixing and matching with whatever you’re wearing. The wool blend material also provides unbeatable comfort, and this hat won’t slide around on your head.
Rave Review: “I love this oversized hat. It’s incredibly warm. I’ve worn it to hike in freezing temperatures and I end up needing to take hat breaks because of how warm it keeps me!”
Best Budget Beanie
Columbia Unisex Whirlibird Cuffed Beanie
Best Budget Beanie
Columbia Unisex Whirlibird Cuffed Beanie
Pros
- High-quality stitching
- Super warm
Cons
- Hand wash only
This cuffed Columbia beanie is super affordable, but doesn’t skimp on its quality. Its acrylic material will keep you warm even in super cool temperatures and includes a subtle, but stylish logo tag. The entire hat is also pulled together with super quality stitching—and Columbia ensures it’s build to last.
Rave Review: “This is, by far, the best winter hat, I have ever had. I am an avid sheller, and winter shelling can be very cold, and this hat keeps me warm.”
Best Lightweight Beanie
Neff Soft Cozy Warm Daily Beanie Hat
Best Lightweight Beanie
Neff Soft Cozy Warm Daily Beanie Hat
Pros
- Extremely stretchy
- Comes in tons of colors
Cons
- Thinner material
A lot of beanies these days are more about the logo than the look, says Berlin. The Neff beanie is a trendy pick, especially if you lean a little more into the camp of wearing a beanie year round. The Neff probably isn’t something you want to go skiing in, but it’ll keep you warm enough on chillier days.
Rave Review: “This is literally the best beanie ever. I have a big head, and always had issues with beanies. These fit well and aren’t too thick either. “
Most Comfortable Beanie
Lululemon Warm Revelation Beanie
Most Comfortable Beanie
Lululemon Warm Revelation Beanie
Pros
- Super quality materials
- Fitted for any head
Cons
- Some colors aren’t true-to-picture
If Lululemon’s leggings feel like butter on your legs, this hat will feel like the (non-gross) equivalent on your head. It’s also super easy to take care of—simply throw it in the wash and you’re all set. If you trust this brand for all your athleisure needs, you’ll know the beanie is worth adding to your cart.
Rave Review: “The best thing about this beanie is, it’s snug, warm, but most of all covers your ears and does not [roll up on your head].”
Best Beanie With Pom Pom
Lululemon Women’s Textured Fleece-Lined Knit Beanie
Best Beanie With Pom Pom
Lululemon Women’s Textured Fleece-Lined Knit Beanie
Now 55% Off
Pros
- Includes a touch cashmere for a soft feel
- Designed for on-the-move wear
Cons
- Some reviews say it looks bulky on smaller heads
And if you want something a bit more stylish from a brand you still love, this cable knit pom beanie will be right up your alley. It’s designed for more on-the-move needs, but it’ll seamlessly pair with any outfit, without making it feel dressed-down. Plus, it’s thick and soft. What else could you want in a beanie?
Rave Review: “This hat is so warm and great for those chilly days. It has great stretch, which I appreciate. Overall a great buy!”
| Material | Wool and cotton blend |
|---|
Best Casual Beanie
Levi’s Levi’s Classic Warm Winter Knit
Best Casual Beanie
Levi’s Levi’s Classic Warm Winter Knit
Pros
- Comes in tons of colors
- Unisex
Cons
- Colors aren’t true-to-picture
This Levi’s beanie is a great alternative if you want something a bit more casual for your winter look. It comes in several different colors, and it fits people of all genders. Plus, if you love a good pair of Levi’s, rep your favorite brand on your head while you’re at it.
Rave Review: “Initially, I got this for my husband. Once I saw it in person, I didn’t want to give it to him anymore! Now, we’re sharing it. He loves it too!”
Best Unisex Beanie
Herschel Men’s Elmer Beanie, Black, One Size
Best Unisex Beanie
Herschel Men’s Elmer Beanie, Black, One Size
Pros
- Won’t bunch up at the top
- Great for larger heads
Cons
- Colors aren’t all true-to-picture
Sometimes, women’s beanies feel a bit too constructive (calling all big heads like me). This Hershel men’s beanie is versatile enough for people of all genders, and you won’t risk it feeling too tight on your noggin. Its woven label is also not too eye-catching, but still provides a nice accent to the plain hat.
Rave Review: “A great beanie with good thickness—still warm but not too hot. It also doesn’t have too much length up top.”
Olivia Evans (she/her) is an editorial assistant at Women’s Health. Her work has previously appeared in The Cut and Teen Vogue. She loves covering topics where culture and wellness intersect. In her free time, she enjoys cooking, running, and watching rom-coms.
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
