Best Oxford Shirts For Men 2024, Tested And Scored

The best Oxford shirts for men are versatile, multi-season wardrobe staples—they can be dressed up or dressed down depending on the occasion, venue or your mood. Oxford shirts are a slightly more casual version of a dress shirt—their hallmarks include a textured, basket weave fabric, and they typically have a chest pocket and button-down collar. After testing a variety of options firsthand, we selected Bonobos’ Everyday Oxford Shirt as the best Oxford shirt for men overall. Everlane Organic Oxford Shirt won as the most comfortable pick while Taylor Stitch’s The Jack Shirt notched a win as the best casual Oxford shirt.

Oxford shirts, based on fit, comfort and quality.

ILLUSTRATION: FORBES / PHOTO: RETAILERS

To uncover the winners, we had a tester—who typically wears formal suits to work and relaxed basics on the weekends—put many shirts through the wringer, evaluating the fit, comfort, quality and style of the top contenders. A handful of picks met our high standards (read more about our testing process at the end). Here, the best Oxford shirts for men that we highly recommend, as well as expert shopping tips.

David Donahue Royal Oxford Dress Shirt

Sizes: Collar 15 to 18.5, sleeve 31 to 37 | Colors: 4 total | Fit: Regular, trim | Machine washable: Yes

What’s notable: It retains a crisp look, with both plastic and metal collar stays.
What could be better: Some feel that it would be helpful to have a pocket.

Think of this as your next trusty work shirt, whether you work in a buttoned up office setting or someplace more informal. With a refined look, spread collar and no pocket, at first this appears like more of a dress shirt, but its woven, heavier cotton makes it a versatile Oxford. It also features adjustable barrel cuffs, a French placket and two back pleats for comfort and freedom of movement.

What our tester says: “This shirt is extremely well constructed and its smooth, refined basketweave fabric give it a dressy look perfect for an office setting. It’s also surprisingly soft, but I may only wear this to work in colder months because of the overall thickness of the fabric. The sleeves are full on the regular fit shirt I ordered, though, and it felt a bit roomier than I’m used to so I’d love to try this in a trim fit.”

Charles Tyrwhitt

Charles Tyrwhitt Button-Down Collar Non-Iron Oxford Shirt

40109Save $69 (63%)

Sizes: Collar 14.5 to 20, sleeve 32 to 38 (and it’s available in custom sleeve length for an additional $17.95 | Colors: 8 total | Fit: Classic, slim, extra slim | Machine washable: Yes

What’s notable: The colors and patterns are understated and easy to wear. There’s also the option to monogram your shirt with your initials for $15.95 or add a left pocket for $12.95.
What could be better: The finer weave of this shirt may wear less well than other oxford shirts over time.

This shirt is more of an Oxford-dress shirt hybrid—it has a button-down collar, but no pocket and it’s a finer, mid-weight fabric than a traditional oxford shirt’s heavy basket weave. The crease-resistant fabric breathes well—even under suit jackets—and maintains a like-new appearance for longer, whether you’re washing it at home or sending it to the dry cleaner.

What our tester says: “This is one of my preferred office shirts because the crease-resistant fabric looks nice even after commuting and long days. I got the slim fit in a 17/35, and it’s pretty relaxed through the shoulders so it allows me to move my arms comfortably without feeling constricted. The buttons are also thicker and expensive looking.”

Sizes: XS to XXL | Colors: 4 total | Fit: Classic, slim | Machine washable: Yes

What’s notable: The softer hand feel of the fabric gives it a worn-in vibe and makes it less rough than many other Oxfords.
What could be better: It’s more limited in fits and colors than some other brands.

Menswear powerhouse Todd Snyder is known for accessible fashion and superb tailoring. This shirt—which comes in sizes XS to XXL instead of collar-arm sizing—is the perfect formal-meets-informal style choice that feels distinctly old school American. A few small style details that set it apart: It has a button at the center of the chest pocket, a button at the back of the collar and a discreet locker loop at the bottom of the yoke between the shoulder blades.

What our tester says: “This shirt has a great feel and is clearly well-made, with nice finishing details everywhere. I found the size large, slim fit to be slimmer than other slim fit Oxfords. It was slightly snug through the shoulder, although it has a pleat at the upper back yoke that offers a bit more room to move.”

Sizes: XS to XXL | Colors: 13 total | Fit: Classic, although available in standard or tall lengths | Machine washable: Yes

What’s notable: It’s made from 100% organic soft cotton, is comfortable and well made.
What could be better: Its baggy fit may not be ideal for many office settings, and no matter where you’re wearing it, you may need to size down.

Consider Everlane’s take a foundational choice for every guy’s wardrobe. It’s sophisticated casual, with a button-down collar and locker loop at the back. It also has a relaxed fit through the body and upper arm to make it comfortable in both elevated and casual settings.

What our tester says: “This shirt is made from a durable and soft basketweave, and it has substantial, thick buttons that feel like they can withstand a lot of wear without popping off. Per the sizing chart I ordered an XL, but the boxy cut was too wide and wasn’t flattering on my 6’3” frame, and the arms felt a bit short. A tall length would’ve been better on me.”

Sizes: XS to XXL | Colors: 8 total | Fit: Standard | Machine washable: Yes

What’s notable: While many lighter-colored Oxford shirts can be somewhat see through, this one is not. The collar remains crisp after washing, too.
What could be better: This shirt runs a little small, so you may have to size up.

This shirt checks all the boxes—it has a button-down collar and chest pocket, and it comes in eight versatile colors, including traditional white and blue along with a less-expected navy university stripe and army green. Part of the beauty of this shirt is that it looks just as good with a crisp press or casually rumpled. The slightly shorter length means it’s meant to be worn untucked. Taylor Stitch also has a repair or replace guarantee and free shipping and returns.

What our tester says: “This was one of the softest shirts I tried, and its worn-in feel made me want to put it on immediately and wear it often. I ordered this in a 42/large, which is my normal size, but this was snug on me—there are no pleats at the back yoke—and it was short in the arms. But still, I liked it so much that I wore it unbuttoned over a t-shirt with the sleeves rolled up.”

Why Trust Forbes Vetted

We spend a lot of time researching and writing about men’s fashion at Forbes Vetted, having covered everything from the most comfortable men’s dress shoes to the best wallets for men. For this story, we reached out to costume designer and Emmy-nominated stylist Paolo Nieddu and seasoned fashion stylist Kate Moroney for insight into the best Oxford shirt fabrics, fits and styling tips. We also had a product tester—who wears an Oxford or dress shirt to work five days a week and has tried countless styles—evaluate each product firsthand, spending hours in each shirt while relaxing, commuting and working in the office.

How We Chose The Best Oxford Shirts

For this story, we first examined Oxford shirts from a broad swath of brands and retailers, recognizing that men are always looking for the perfect sophisticated casual shirt. We investigated options from more established shirtmakers as well as smaller, boutique fashion brands and everything in between. To make the cut, shirts had to come in luxe fabrics, offer impeccable and varied fits, be available in variable sizing options and color options, and potentially have special features like fabric stretch, machine washability or monogramming. Furthermore, reviews had to be overwhelmingly positive, and each shirt had to receive high marks from our tester.

What To Consider When Shopping For An Oxford Shirt

While it may seem like the Oxford shirt’s origins are rooted in preppy Americana, the shirt was in fact initially produced in Scotland in the 19th century. Today, it remains popular for its breathability, durability and fits-all-occasions adaptability. “Oxford shirts are a must because they look great on everyone,” says Nieddu. “They are ageless, timeless and seasonless and can be worn on almost any occasion.” The best Oxford men’s shirts for men come in durable cottons, wearable colors and comfortable, flattering fits—and should be easy to care for

Fabric

Oxford shirts are traditionally a durable basket weave cotton shirt, but some brands offer them in more refined weaves. “The classic oxford fabric is made with a textured, breathable cotton, and it can show a bit of wrinkling or creasing,” says Moroney. “It’s not a classic fitted, perfectly ironed dress shirt—it often has a little more of a rugged feel.” In general, Oxford shirt fabrics can feel stiff or slightly rough at first but will soften with time. If you have an athletic build, or are an active commute or travel often, a shirt with stretch may be ideal so that it moves with you.

Sizing

Some men’s shirts come in more general sizing—think XS to XXL—while others allow you to specify collar size and sleeve length when purchasing. If you prefer a more precise fit for the office, this may be the best choice for you.

Fit Options

Lots of brands—like Todd Snyder, Bonobos and Charles Tyrwhitt—come in different silhouettes, such as classic, slim or athletic. In most brands, slim is a more contemporary fit, while classic tends to run on the roomy side. Consider whether you may prefer a more streamlined fit if you plan to wear your shirt under a suit jacket or sweater, or if something looser and casual is more your style.

Length

Finally, when considering which Oxford shirt to purchase, consider your height and whether you’ll wear your shirt tucked or untucked. Certain brands, such as Bonobos and Everlane, offer short and long lengths. “If you’re wearing your Oxford shirt untucked and it covers your entire butt, it’s too long,” says Moroney.

Special Details

Bear in mind that a chest pocket is a pretty standard feature on an Oxford shirt, but some are pocket-less. Button-down collars are typically another hallmark. Less frequently, you’ll see a locker loop at the back of the shirt and a button on the collar at the back of the neck.

Are Oxford Shirts Casual Or Formal?

They can be both. “Because it is so classic and iconic, the Oxford can be worn in so many casual or formal ways,” says Nieddu. While traditionally Oxford shirts skewed more casual, Moroney points out that now they are a wardrobe staple that can be worn with everything from a suit to chinos to jeans. More casual versions of an Oxford have a more textured, thick basketweave. Dressier versions have a thinner, more refined weave and may not have a button-down collar or pocket.

What Is The Best Oxford Shirt?

There are so many great ones that it’s hard to choose, but our pick for best Oxford shirt overall is Bonobos’ Everyday Oxford Shirt for its variety of fits, lengths and colors as well as its stretchy and machine washable material and its conservative price point.

How Should An Oxford Shirt Fit?

Part of this has to do with where you’ll wear it, and part of it has to do with what type of fit you like. In general, the more casual the venue the more relaxed the fit. If you’ll be wearing it to work, you’ll likely want an Oxford shirt that fits a bit closer to the body. But your body type and style sensibility will also determine the best fit for you. If you spend hours lifting weights at the gym you may prefer an athletic fit, whereas if you’re tall and slim a tailored, slim or extra slim fit may look best on you. A helpful pro tip: “Always check that the shoulder seam does not go past the slope of your shoulder and that the sleeve length ends at your wrist or no more than an inch past,” says Nieddu. “Too-short sleeves can throw the proportions off and can look less polished, but if they’re too long you can always roll them up,” says Moroney. Also, there shouldn’t be any pulling at your chest, she says. The length should be able to be worn tucked or untucked, with the hem stopping at the middle of your butt.

How Should I Style An Oxford Shirt?

For dressier occasions, “try an Oxford under a suit with a tie, or pair it with a blazer and tie with chinos,” says Nieddu. “Another great way to wear an Oxford is under a cashmere or wool sweater with trousers,” he says. “This could be considered casual but chic enough to wear to the office or dinner out.” Alternatively, try it paired simply with your favorite jeans, loosely tucked and with a great belt or chinos for a classic casual look. “Oxfords also look great with the sleeves rolled up with a great pair of shorts for a cool summer look,” Nieddu says.